Explore accurate parcel and ownership records,
directly sourced from county assessors.
Tucked into Idaho's southeastern corner along the Utah border, Bear Lake County is home to one of the most striking natural features in the American West — Bear Lake itself, a glacially-fed reservoir so brilliantly turquoise it's earned the nickname "Caribbean of the Rockies." That scenic identity shapes everything about this county's real estate market, from its remarkably low prices to one of the most unusual vacancy rates you'll find anywhere in Idaho.
| Stat | Value | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Median Home Value | $234,200 | 27% below national median of $320,000 |
| Homeownership Rate | 85.0% | well above national avg ~65% |
| Vacancy Rate | 41.5% | nearly 4x the national benchmark ~10% |
| Median Rent | $687 | strikingly affordable but still burden-heavy |
Here's the headline number that demands explanation: 41.5% of Bear Lake County's housing units sit vacant. With only 3,943 total units and 2,308 occupied households, over 1,600 homes are effectively empty on any given census day. This isn't blight — it's seasonal ownership. Bear Lake is a destination. Families from the Wasatch Front, just a few hours north, maintain second homes and cabins along the shoreline, many of which count as "vacant" in census tallies. The county's tourism economy essentially runs a dual housing market: a modest, year-round residential layer and a much larger seasonal layer beneath it.
That dynamic also explains why median home values — at $234,200 — feel almost suspiciously low for a lakefront community with genuine natural cachet. Much of the pricing reflects modest inland homes and agricultural land, not the premium lakefront inventory that likely commands multiples of that figure.
Despite the scenic backdrop, Bear Lake County's economic core is grounded in agriculture, ranching, and small-scale commerce in towns like Paris and Montpelier. The unemployment rate of just 2.6% signals a genuinely tight local labor market — almost everyone who wants to work is working. Yet labor force participation sits at only 57.2%, well below national norms, largely explained by a population that skews both young (27.1% under 18) and older (nearly 21% over 65). This is a place with a lot of families and retirees, not a commuter-heavy workforce county.
Educational attainment is modest by national standards — just 14% hold a bachelor's degree, and 36.4% stopped at a high school diploma — but this hasn't translated into economic desperation. At $67,304, the median household income falls below the national figure but comfortably supports local home prices at roughly a 3.5x price-to-income ratio, actually better than the national benchmark.
One data point cuts against the affordability narrative: 37.6% of renters are cost-burdened, exceeding the 30% threshold, despite a median rent of just $687. With only 15% of households renting — among the lowest rates in Idaho — the rental market is thin and likely strained by competition from seasonal demand. When tourists and seasonal workers compete with year-round renters for a tiny pool of units, even low absolute rents become a stretch for local wage earners.
What makes Bear Lake County, Idaho unique in real estate terms? Bear Lake County combines one of Idaho's most dramatic natural amenities — Bear Lake — with small-town agricultural character and genuinely affordable home prices. Its extraordinary 41.5% vacancy rate reflects a large seasonal second-home market rather than economic distress, making it a rare place where affordability and desirability coexist.
Is Bear Lake County a good place to buy a vacation home? It has historically been exactly that for Utah and Idaho residents. Proximity to the Wasatch Front (roughly 2 hours from Salt Lake City), low property values relative to comparable lake destinations, and a well-established seasonal community make it attractive. The caveat is infrastructure — public transit is nonexistent, broadband reaches 89.6% of homes but gaps remain, and services are limited year-round.
Why is rent so cheap in Bear Lake County but renters still struggle? At $687 median rent, Bear Lake looks affordable in absolute terms. But local wages in an agricultural, service-oriented economy can be modest, and the rental market is extremely small and uncompetitive. When seasonal demand tightens availability, even low rents consume a disproportionate share of local incomes.
Get instant access to comprehensive county assessors-based property data with your free API key
Need Bulk Data?
Email us at hello@realie.ai