Property details·New Carlisle, Laporte County, Indiana·46-04-07-400-008.000-050
10429 North 650 East
New Carlisle, IN 46552
Laporte County
46-04-07-400-008.000-050
41.758125, -86.569013
| Category | Amount | Year |
|---|---|---|
| Tax value | $1,972.92 | 2026 |
| Market value | $169,900 | 2025 |
| Assessed value | $169,900 | 2026 |
| Building value | $122,200 | — |
| Land value | $47,700 | — |
Values reflect public tax roll data as of the year shown.
County context
There's a real estate paradox quietly playing out in LaPorte County. Tucked into the northwestern corner of Indiana — just an hour southeast of Chicago and a short drive from the Lake Michigan shoreline — this county of 112,000 residents offers genuine affordability in a region where affordability has become increasingly scarce. At $180,000 for a median-priced home, buyers here are getting Midwest value within commuting distance of one of the most expensive metro areas in the country. The question is why more people haven't noticed yet — and whether the recent price data suggests the window may be cracking.
| Stat | Value | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Median Home Value | $180,700 | 43% below national median of $320,000 |
| Homeownership Rate | 74.6% | well above national average (~65%) |
| YoY Price Change | -23.0% | sharp correction after post-pandemic run-up |
| Rent Burden Rate | 40.3% | exceeds the 30% affordability threshold |
The headline number that demands explanation is the 23% year-over-year price decline. That's a significant drop — the kind that raises eyebrows — but context matters. LaPorte County, like many smaller Midwest markets, caught a wave of pandemic-era interest as remote workers and Chicago-area buyers sought space and value. What's happening now looks more like a reversion toward pre-2020 norms than a structural collapse. With 113 recent sales logged against a backdrop of 49,878 total housing units and a 12.4% vacancy rate, the market is thin in terms of active transactions, which amplifies price volatility in the data. A handful of high-value or distressed sales can swing the median meaningfully in a county this size.
One of the genuinely striking features of LaPorte County is how deeply embedded homeownership is in the local identity. At 74.6%, the ownership rate significantly outpaces the national average — and it's supported by the housing stock itself: 78.1% single-family homes, with a median build year of 1956 that tells the story of postwar industrial prosperity. Michigan City and La Porte, the county's two main population centers, grew alongside the steel and manufacturing economy of the southern Lake Michigan basin. That era built solid, affordable housing stock that continues to underpin accessibility today.
Here's the contradiction: in a county this affordable to own, renters are getting squeezed. A median rent of $926 against household incomes that trail the national benchmark means 40.3% of renters are burdened — above the standard 30% threshold — and 18.1% face severe burden. With a labor force participation rate of just 57.3% and a child poverty rate of 23.1% (notably higher than the overall 14% poverty rate), there's a clear two-track economy at work. The ownership class is doing reasonably well. The renting class is stretched.
LaPorte County's education profile reflects a county that built its identity around skilled trades rather than college degrees. Nearly 40% of residents hold only a high school diploma, and just 14.4% have a bachelor's degree — roughly half the national average. That's not necessarily a liability in a region still anchored in logistics, light manufacturing, and healthcare, but it does constrain wage growth and economic diversification over the long term.
What makes LaPorte County, Indiana unique? LaPorte County occupies a rare geographic sweet spot: close enough to Chicago to capture spillover demand, yet priced like the deep Midwest. Add dune country, Lake Michigan access at Michigan City's Washington Park Beach, and a strong ownership culture, and you get a county that quietly punches above its demographic weight as a place to actually live — not just pass through.
Is LaPorte County a good place to buy a home right now? For buyers, the combination of sub-$200,000 median prices, high ownership rates, and a post-pandemic correction creating negotiating room makes 2024-2025 an interesting entry window. The real risk is the thin transaction volume, which means liquidity — your ability to sell quickly if needed — is more limited than in denser metro markets.
Why is child poverty so high in LaPorte County despite moderate home values? The 23.1% child poverty rate reflects a county with significant economic stratification. Homeowning households tend to be stable and older (median age 40.8, with nearly 19% over 65), while younger families — more likely to be renters — face a tighter income-to-cost squeeze, particularly given the labor force participation rate lagging national norms.
Our database includes 6,010 properties in New Carlisle.
With an average price of $312,640, New Carlisle offers mid-range housing options.
Buyers can expect to pay around $178 per square foot in this market.
Home prices in New Carlisle are 50% higher than the Laporte County average.
| Metric | New Carlisle | Laporte County | vs County |
|---|---|---|---|
| Average Price | $312,640 | $208,299 | +50% |
| Avg Sq Ft | 1,761 | 1,898 | -7% |
| Price/Sq Ft | $178 | $110 | +62% |
| Properties | 6,010 | 76,186 | -92% |
Other parcels within a few hundred meters of this one.
The average home price in New Carlisle, IN is $312,640, based on analysis of 6,010 properties in our database.
Our database includes 6,010 properties in New Carlisle, IN, providing comprehensive market coverage.
The average price per square foot in New Carlisle, IN is $178. This is calculated from an average home price of $312,640 and average size of 1,761 square feet.
Homes in New Carlisle, IN average 1,761 square feet, with an average price of $312,640.
New Carlisle, IN is one of many cities in Laporte County, IN with property data available. Browse other cities in the county to compare market conditions and pricing.
Access owner information, tax records, transfer history, and more through our API.
View API pricingGet instant access to comprehensive county assessors-based property data with your free API key
Need Bulk Data?
Email us at hello@realie.ai