Suffolk County, New York
Explore accurate parcel and ownership records,
directly sourced from county assessors.
Our database includes 2,818 properties in Shelter Island.
The average home price of $1.4M positions Shelter Island as a premium real estate market.
At $589/sq ft, property values here are significantly above national averages.
Home prices in Shelter Island are 76% higher than the Suffolk County average.
Showing page 35 of properties
The average home price in Shelter Island, NY is $1,394,319, based on analysis of 2,818 properties in our database.
Our database includes 2,818 properties in Shelter Island, NY, providing comprehensive market coverage.
The average price per square foot in Shelter Island, NY is $589. This is calculated from an average home price of $1,394,319 and average size of 2,369 square feet.
Homes in Shelter Island, NY average 2,369 square feet, with an average price of $1,394,319.
Shelter Island, NY is one of many cities in Suffolk County, NY with property data available. Browse other cities in the county to compare market conditions and pricing.
Get instant access to comprehensive county assessors-based property data with your free API key
Need Bulk Data?
Email us at hello@realie.ai